Unique Engagement Rings, Before The Stone Becomes A Story

Three engagement stories exploring sapphire, heirloom, and nontraditional rings shaped by the people and lives they were made for.

There's no single arc an engagement takes, and no single ring that belongs to it. These are three stories, three relationships, and three approaches to a unique engagement ring, each shaped by the specifics of the lives they were made for.

Every Ring Its Own Answer

A traditional diamond engagement ring is one answer among many. An engagement ring marks one beginning, but it's also an invitation to imagine the most personal expression that it can take. Perhaps that’s choosing unconventional gemstones instead of a diamond engagement ring, or a less expected ring setting. Maybe it’s writing entirely new traditions around what these rings can represent, how they can be worn, and by whom. 

We think of an engagement ring as an open question, asked differently each time: what can this ring hold, and how can it tell that story? Some couples arrive already knowing the answer. Others find it through the sourcing, the sketching, the trying-on, the surprising themselves. There's no incorrect way; there is only your way.

Shayla & Jack

Our conversation with Shayla and Jack is an example of breaking convention with nontraditional engagement rings matched to their lifestyle. A nurse and a teacher in Connecticut, they both wanted engagement rings and planned to skip wedding bands entirely.

Their conversation started with a practical question. Shayla needed a ring she could wear comfortably through her hospital shifts: no prongs to snag a glove, no setting raised high enough to catch on anything. She came in eyeing a pear-shaped signet in a moody blue-teal sapphire, but when she came in for her fitting she gravitated toward a menhir ring, a cigar band with a low bezel-set pear, with the stone held flush against the edge. Jack wanted an engagement ring, too, and selected our eye signet with a beautifully distinct lapis— an opaque blue with pyrite flecked through the stone. Side by side, the stones in both rings read as two expressions of the same color; each uniquely their own but undoubtedly in conversation.

What makes an engagement ring nontraditional?[+] [-]

A nontraditional engagement ring can depart from convention through its stone, setting, silhouette, or the way it is worn. At WWAKE, this might mean choosing a sapphire or alternative gemstone, exploring an unexpected setting, reimagining an heirloom stone, or creating a custom design shaped around the person who will wear it.

Can WWAKE create a custom engagement ring around how I want to wear it?[+] [-]

Yes. A custom engagement ring can begin with a WWAKE design you’d like to reimagine or with an entirely new idea. Our Engagement Ring Guide is a useful place to explore stones, settings, and styles before you begin. From there, our Fine Jewelry Specialists guide the design, stone selection, setting, and proportions, with a complete proposal and visual mockup shared before your piece is crafted in our New York studio.

How do I begin a custom engagement ring with WWAKE?[+] [-]

Browse our Ceremonial Collection for inspiration, considering the shapes, stones, and settings you’re drawn to. From there, complete our custom questionnaire and meet with a Fine Jewelry Specialist. Consultations can take place at our Greenpoint showroom or virtually, so you don’t need to be in New York to begin. Visit Custom by WWAKE to learn more about the process and what to expect.

Meg & Brian

Meg and Brian's engagement ring is one of the most romantic ideas we've encountered: a Toi et Moi ring set with two sapphires, chosen in the colors of their own eyes. 

French for "you and me," classic Toi et Moi rings are already a love story in miniature; two stones, side by side in one ring. To create Meg's sapphire engagement ring, we studied photographs of each of their eyes to find a match in gemstones, exploring variations in tone and saturation. Up close, an eye is never a single color; it's a gradient, flecked and layered, closer to a landscape than a swatch. A sapphire holds color the same way, which is what made the two so well matched.

Are sapphires a good choice for engagement rings?[+] [-]

Yes. Sapphires are durable enough for everyday wear and occur in a remarkable range of colors, from blues to pinks, greens, yellows, violets, and near-colorless tones. That variation makes a sapphire engagement ring an especially personal alternative to a traditional diamond engagement ring. 

Can I choose a sapphire instead of a diamond for a custom engagement ring?[+] [-]

Yes. WWAKE works exclusively with natural diamonds and gemstones, and our custom process gives you access to stones from our in-house vault as well as a curated selection sourced by our dedicated Stone Sourcing Specialist. Color, cut, character, and origin can all become part of finding the stone around which your ring is designed. For more on diamond carat, cut, color, and clarity, explore our Diamond Guide.

Can WWAKE help me find a specific color of sapphire?[+] [-]

Yes. If the right stone isn’t already in our collection, our dedicated stone specialist can source a curated selection of natural diamonds and gemstones through WWAKE’s trusted network. We consider each stone individually, looking at its color, character, origin, and how it complements the design, while staying true to our commitment to thoughtful and responsible sourcing. Learn more about our approach in the WWAKE Ethos.

Maggi & Ryan

Maggi’s ring holds three generations in one stone: she arrived to our studio with a blue diamond that had been passed down from great-grandmother to granddaughter to great-granddaughter, ready for its next chapter. 

To bring it into the present, we reset it into our Dyad ring, paired beside a vibrant bi-colored Australian sapphire chosen to meet the diamond's blue without competing with it. We loved designing something that could continue the personal sentimentality of a family stone without needing it to be a replica. Tradition isn't kept alive by staying still, but by being chosen again and again. 

Can an heirloom stone be used in a new engagement ring?[+] [-]

Yes. WWAKE can work with natural heirloom stones to create a new piece around what you already have. Our Heirloom Resetting process is designed to preserve the history and sentiment of the original while giving the stone a form made to be worn now. Depending on the piece, documentation of origin may be requested for loose stones. 

How does WWAKE’s heirloom resetting process work?[+] [-]

Begin by sharing your heirloom’s history, photos, measurements, and ideas through our questionnaire and consultation. Once WWAKE receives the piece, the stone is inspected in person to assess its condition and suitability for the proposed design. You’ll then receive a design proposal with visual mockups and pricing before the piece is reworked in our New York studio. The process typically takes 6–8 weeks from design approval.

Can WWAKE add another stone to my heirloom engagement ring?[+] [-]

Yes, where the design calls for it. After assessing your heirloom, WWAKE’s dedicated Stone Sourcing Specialist can source complementary natural stones through our trusted network, allowing an inherited stone to become part of a new composition.

A Place to Begin

Whether you're drawn to a sapphire over a diamond engagement ring, curious about alternative stones, or are curious about unique wedding rings that carry the same spirit forward, reach out: our custom team is happy to explore the possibilities with you. 

Beyond the Traditional Engagement Ring

Shop [75]

An engagement ring doesn’t have to follow tradition. Explore distinctive WWAKE designs, find a One Of A Kind ring, create something custom, or reimagine an heirloom into a piece that tells your story.

Support

Our client care team is available Monday to Friday from 10am-5pm EDT

Studio

WWAKE Studio
Brooklyn, NY 11222 USA

Contact

Have a question?

Our team is here to assist with general inquiries, custom projects, and anything else you may need. We’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Jewelry to be worn, kept and carried forward.

Explore Our Engagement Ring Guide

Jewelry to be worn, kept and carried forward.

Explore Our Engagement Ring Guide